Rethinking Water Affordability: Multicriteria Frameworks for Water Tariff Reform
University of Brawijaya, Indonesia
University of Tulungagung, Indonesia
Abstract
The issue of water tariffs and services is a multifaceted one involving not only operational and investment costs but also social, economic, environmental, and political considerations. In Indonesia, water tariff policies have largely focused on cost recovery, often neglecting equity, affordability, and environmental sustainability, which are key principles aligned with SDGS 6, which is the right to clean water and sanitation. This study aims to provide an evidence-based approach to water tariff design that integrates these issues to support sustainable and inclusive water services. This study employed the Analytical Hierarchy Process (AHP) within a multicriteria decision-making framework. Data were collected through structured questionnaires and pairwise comparisons involving 31 participants, comprising 24 local stakeholders (policymakers, service providers, and consumers) and 7 subject-matter experts, then it was analysed using Expert Choice software. The results indicate that economic condition holds the highest priority (36%), followed by user preference (34%), and accessibility (30%). Among policy alternatives, the progressive cross-subsidy tariff model ranked highest. The progressive cross-subsidy tariff model emerges as the most effective policy with low basic consumption rates and targeted subsidies based on household economic data. It effectively balances affordability for low-income households with the financial sustainability of regional water utilities. These findings imply that local governments need to implement progressive cross-subsidy tariffs with low basic consumption rates, and targeted subsidies based on household economic data.
1 Introduction
Behind the seemingly simple flow of water from household taps lies a complex set of challenges concerning who bears the cost and how equitable the tariffs truly are. Data from the Ministry of Public Works and Housing 2023 show that non-revenue water in Indonesia’s regional water utilities remains at 33.7%, with unused service capacity reaching nearly 26,000 litres per second (KOMPAS 2023). This reveals a critical state of operational inefficiency that, if not addressed, threatens the long-term sustainability of clean water services (Arbués et al. 2003; Molinos-Senante et al. 2019). At the same time, weak public participation in tariff-setting processes adds another layer of complexity. Limited community involvement often opens the way for technocratic dominance and short-term political considerations in decision-making (Bel 2020). This phenomenon underscores that water tariffs are not simply numbers on a cost table; they reflect a contested arena where the goals of service sustainability, social justice, and the fundamental right to water intersect.
The determination of water tariffs is far more than a matter of calculating operational costs and capital investments; it also requires consideration of social, economic, environmental, and political concerns. Historically, water pricing instruments have been the subject of extensive debate in water policy studies, particularly with domestic consumption (Zhong and Mol 2008). Numerous studies have concluded that household water consumption tends to be inelastic, that is, relatively unresponsive to price changes (Jiang et al. 2022; Sandoval et al. 2025; Wen et al. 2023). Conventional studies estimating household water demand functions report price elasticities below one, implying that price increases do not immediately or substantially reduce water use (Massarutto 2020; Zhong and Mol 2008).
An alternative and increasingly relevant approach employs the Stone-Geary utility function, which acknowledges that part of domestic water consumption is essential and cannot be reduced even when prices increase (Arbués et al. 2003; Arbués and García-Valiñas 2020; Bel 2020). Although limited studies using this approach provide important insights that pricing instruments alone have limited capacity to influence consumption efficiency because much of domestic water use fulfills basic needs that are insensitive to price signals (Fuente 2019). Nonetheless, households are not entirely insensitive to tariff reforms, and their responsiveness depends strongly on socio-economic context and household characteristics (Roibas et al. 2019). Fair and sustainable tariff policies reflect this heterogeneity. Unfortunately, tariff setting in Indonesia has been largely driven by a cost-recovery logic, focused narrowly on covering operational and investment expenses, while neglecting social equity, affordability for vulnerable groups, and environmental sustainability.
In the context of public service, access to clean water is a basic human right, not merely a commodity. Tariff policies must incorporate multidimensional considerations that balance financial sustainability with the ability of households to pay (Massarutto 2020; Roibas et al. 2019). In practice, local governments often struggle to strike a balance between the financial sustainability of regional water companies and the economic capacity of their communities. Low tariffs may keep water affordable, but at the cost of service quality and continuity, while high tariffs may generate revenue but risk excluding poor households from access (Vázquez-Serrano et al. 2025).
From the community perspective, the success of regional water supply programs cannot be measured solely by the availability of infrastructure (Suárez-Varela et al. 2015). Three interrelated factors shape the acceptance and effectiveness of these services. First, accessibility, influenced by the distance and time required to reach water sources, as well as the quality and continuity of supply (Barberán et al. 2022; von Lieres et al. 2025; Zhong and Mol 2008). When access is difficult, people are reluctant to use the service even when prices are low. Second, willingness to subscribe, which depends heavily on perceptions of water service quality, satisfaction with water quality, and prior experiences with clean water services (Arbués and García-Valiñas 2020; Jiang et al. 2022; Massarutto 2020). Third, the ability to pay, which is influenced by household income, expenditure patterns, housing conditions, and awareness of the value of clean water (Massarutto 2020; Pinto et al. 2021; Sandoval et al. 2025).
These three factors of accessibility, willingness to sign up for, and economic capacity, directly determine the level of demand and participation in regional water supply programs. When these factors are weak, subscription rates decrease, which affects the overall performance of the system (Molinos-Senante et al. 2019). Given this complexity, decision-making frameworks that rely solely on cost-recovery principles are insufficient because they ignore the socio-economic conditions and preferences of the community (Fuente 2019). There is a clear need for a Multicriteria Decision Analysis (MCDA) framework that integrates technical, social, economic, and environmental factors. The Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) of MCDA offers a structured approach to assign weights and make pairwise comparisons among criteria, thereby generating systematic and transparent priorities for tariff policy decisions (Hagage et al. 2025).
Recent years have witnessed a growing application of decision-making tools in water-related research, such as AHP (Hagage et al. 2025; Sangawi et al. 2023), frequency ratio (Reynaud et al. 2018), weights-of-evidence (Kumari et al. 2021), logistic regression (Rajendran et al. 2020; Schleich and Hillenbrand 2019), decision trees (Hagage et al. 2025), linear discriminant analysis, and artificial neural networks (Lopez-Nicolas et al. 2018). Among these methods, AHP, developed by Thomas Saaty in 1980, has proven to be one of the most adaptable and transparent techniques for addressing complex decision-making problems, particularly in the field of water resources management (Chowdhury et al. 2010; Hajkowicz and Higgins 2008; Kaliraj et al. 2014).
While these approaches are widely used for geospatial and hydrogeological modeling such as groundwater recharge zone identification (Rajendran et al. 2020; Sangawi et al. 2023), their application in public policy, especially in water tariff determination, remains very limited. Much of the existing literature has emphasized technical and physical dimensions of water systems, while failing to incorporate socio-economic, institutional, and political aspects that are essential for designing sustainable tariff policies (Arbués and García-Valiñas 2020; Barberán et al. 2022; Bel 2020; Jiang et al. 2022; Pinto et al. 2021; Pronti and Berbel 2023). This gap is particularly evident in developing countries, where tariff structures often prioritize cost-recovery without incorporating household ability to pay, willingness to connect, or satisfaction with service quality.
This study is derived from the observation that water tariff decisions in many regions of Indonesia still rarely employ evidence-based, participatory approaches. By applying MCDA combined with AHP, this research seeks to develop a more comprehensive evaluation framework. A notable limitation in existing studies is the lack of integration between expert-driven MCDA models and empirical, household-level data on consumption behavior, elasticity, and access (Massarutto 2020; Zhong and Mol 2008). The heavy reliance on expert judgement in AHP risks generating biased outcomes because of subjectivity and conflicting expert perspectives (Saaty 1990). These concerns call for hybrid approaches that combine expert assessments with quantitative survey data to ground tariff decisions in local realities.
In this context, accessibility, willingness to sign up for water services, and economic conditions emerge as key criteria for designing tariff structures and prioritizing interventions. At the same time, rising pressures on water systems from population growth, urbanization, climate change, and industrialization further demand that local governments adopt sustainable water management strategies (Pinto et al. 2021). Tariffs must be conceived not merely as financial instruments, but also as policy tools to regulate consumption, encourage water conservation, and promote fair access. Using a case study from a region currently developing a water supply program, this study integrates quantitative household survey data and socio-economic assessments with the AHP methodology to identify the priority factors influencing subscription willingness and capacity. The results aim to provide practical guidance for local governments and regional water services in formulating locally appropriate water tariff policies, strengthening policy legitimacy, and enhancing the success of regional water supply programs.
2 Literature Review
Water tariffs are widely recognized as a policy instrument with the potential to achieve multiple public policy objectives, including efficiency, sustainability, equity, and cost recovery (Barberán et al. 2022). Due to their complex and multidimensional nature, a wide body of research has explored different aspects of water tariffs, covering issues such as progressivity (Arbués and García-Valiñas 2020), price increases (Schleich and Hillenbrand 2019), affordability (Bel 2020), sustainability (Lopez-Nicolas et al. 2018), equity (Jiang et al. 2022), welfare (Molinos-Senante et al. 2019), and cost-recovery capacity (Pronti and Berbel 2023). As a demand management tool, pricing has been shown to negatively affect household water consumption (Fuente 2019; Sandoval et al. 2025). However, complex tariff structures such as increasing block tariffs (IBTs) that combine fixed quotas with tiered pricing, often make it difficult for consumers to understand the relationship between their bills and the volume of water consumed (Pinto et al. 2021).
A growing number of studies have focused on the effects of water tariff reforms on consumption patterns. Simulations examining shifts from linear tariffs to IBT structures demonstrate that such reforms can alter household expenditure distribution and consumption patterns (Suárez-Fernández et al. 2022; Wen et al. 2023). The design of the first block under IBT is crucial to ensuring fairness and affordability, as it must account for basic household needs (Pinto et al. 2021). For instance, Vázquez-Serrano et al. (2025) show that a fixed charge in the first block, combined with a non-linear pricing structure, can improve household welfare compared to uniform pricing.
Alternative mechanisms, such as social tariffs, have also been introduced to protect vulnerable households; however, their implementation is frequently influenced by short-term political considerations rather than actual economic vulnerability (Fuente 2019). Research further suggests that IBT structures are more effective than across-the-board price increases in reducing inequality in water expenditure (Wen et al. 2023). Nonetheless, if poorly designed, progressive block tariffs such as IBTs can lead to financial losses for utilities or trigger price increases for other users when cross-subsidization is not appropriately managed.
Regarding cost recovery and efficiency, several studies emphasize the need to adjust tariffs based on factors such as household size, per capita use, and climate or hydrological data (Sandoval et al. 2025; Sangawi et al. 2023). More dynamic and context-specific tariff designs can reduce the burden on households without undermining the financial sustainability of utilities. Pinto et al. (2021) for example, recommend the introduction of time-based block tariffs to reduce water use during peak periods, while Lopez-Nicolas et al. (2018) propose a two-block structure that is responsive to water scarcity. Natural and quasi-experiments have also been widely employed to assess the real impacts of tariff reforms. Studies by Pinto et al. (2021), and Reynaud et al. (2018), reveal that IBT structures can reduce water consumption, particularly in high-use households. However, these effects vary depending on the demand structure and the socio-economic context of users. For instance, Kumari et al. (2021) find that reductions in consumption are temporary or even insignificant in some contexts.
Variations in price elasticity have also become a major focus in recent research. Schleich and Hillenbrand (2019), and Suárez-Varela et al. (2015), identify asymmetric responses depending on the direction of price changes. In some cases, low-use households even increase their consumption after tariff reforms. Other studies confirm heterogeneous responses to tariff changes, as demonstrated by Fuente (2019) who identified three types of household responses to IBT reforms in Japan. Finally, field experiments incorporating monetary incentives have shown the potential to influence water consumption behavior (Sandoval et al. 2025). Although the literature on water tariff reforms is extensive and employs diverse methodological approaches, relatively few studies explicitly examine the differences in household responses to structural tariff changes.
3 Method
The Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) is a decision-making method that decomposes a complex problem into a hierarchical structure consisting of a goal, criteria, sub-criteria, and alternatives (Saaty 1990). This process facilitates policymakers in organizing and synthesizing information from complex situations in order to develop structured preference options (Hagage et al. 2025). In this study, AHP is applied to analyze factors affecting water tariff policies by comparing multiple criteria, such as accessibility to water sources, user preferences, and household economic conditions, and to assist policymakers in establishing priorities based on the resulting weights (Kumari et al. 2021). Through this approach, AHP provides a systematic and transparent framework that integrates social, technical, and economic considerations into the design of a fair and sustainable tariff structure, ultimately influencing the willingness and ability of households to subscribe to piped water services.
3.1 Research criteria and sub-criteria
The objective of this study is to develop a structured framework to prioritize the factors that influence willingness and ability to subscribe to piped water services, which in turn serves as a foundation for designing fair and sustainable water tariff policies. To achieve this objective, the Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) is employed to establish the criteria and sub-criteria that will guide the evaluation of these factors. In this study, AHP is used to capture the perspectives of multiple stakeholders, ensuring that the weighting of priorities is evidence-based and transparent. The hierarchical structure constructed in this research reflects the core dimensions that must be considered in understanding subscription behavior:
- Accessibility of drinking water sources,
- User preferences, and
- Household economic conditions.
Each main criterion consists of sub-criteria that act as indicators in assessing community willingness and ability to subscribe. Stakeholders (households, PDAM managers, and local government) provide pairwise comparisons through structured questionnaires to derive the relative weights of each criterion and sub-criterion.
To develop the research questionnaire, these criteria and sub-criteria were identified through an extensive literature review, field observation, and consultation with experts in public policy, water utilities, and community development. Detailed definitions of the sub-criteria are provided in Table 1. These elements constitute the analytical basis for evaluating which factors most strongly influence the success of piped water service programs, and for proposing water tariff adjustments that balance financial sustainability, affordability, and social equity.
Table 1 Detailed criteria and sub-criteria definitions.
| Criteria | Sub-criteria | Reference |
| Accessibility | Distance and travel time | Barberán et al. 2022; Zhong and Mol 2008 |
| Quality and continuity of water | von Lieres et al. 2025 | |
| User preference | Willingness to sign up for regional water company services | Barberán et al. 2022; Pinto et al. 2021 |
| Satisfaction with current water source | Arbués et al. 2003; Jiang et al. 2022; Massarutto 2020; Zhong and Mol 2008 | |
| Economic condition | Household expenditure for drinking water | Massarutto 2020; Pinto et al. 2021; Suárez-Fernández et al. 2022 |
| Household income | Massarutto 2020 | |
| Physical condition of the dwelling | Sandoval et al. 2025 | |
| Ownership of assets | Cook and Brent 2021 |
3.2 Analytic Hierarchy Process construction
To systematically examine the factors that shape household willingness and ability to subscribe to piped water services, this study applies the Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP). A four-level hierarchy has been designed to decompose the decision-making process into more manageable components (Figure 1). The first level defines the research goal, which is to identify and prioritize the factors that influence the water tariff policy that are fair, inclusive, and sustainable. The second level consists of three main criteria that are crucial for evaluating the conditions affecting water subscription:
- Accessibility to drinking water sources,
- User preference, and
- Household economic condition.

Figure 1 Analysis hierarchy constructs.
The third level consists of eight sub-criteria (indicators) that represent more specific aspects of each criterion:
- For accessibility, distance, and travel time to water sources, and the quality and continuity of these sources.
- For user preference, willingness to subscribe to regional water company services, and satisfaction with current water sources.
- For economic conditions, household expenditure on water, household income, physical condition of the dwelling, and asset ownership.
These sub-criteria are used to assess the strengths and weaknesses of different service strategies and tariff considerations. They provide the basis for logical and structured decision-making to achieve the research goal. Finally, the fourth level (alternatives) represents the outputs of the analysis:
- The level of willingness to subscribe to water services, and
- The level of ability to subscribe.
These outputs reflect how different factors influence subscription behavior and will be used to inform decisions on tariff structuring. This hierarchy allows the complex issue of water tariff policy to be approached in a structured way. Through pairwise comparisons, AHP enables the assessment of the relative importance of each factor, which ultimately informs evidence-based policy recommendations for water tariffs.
3.3 Pairwise comparisons and stakeholder judgements
The opinions and assessments of stakeholders constitute a crucial stage in the AHP procedure. Through structured questionnaires, stakeholders are invited to evaluate the relative importance of each criterion and sub-criterion using a pairwise comparison scale, as presented in Table 2.
Table 2 Saaty’s scale.
| Score | Descriptions |
| 1 | Both criteria are equally important |
| 2 | Slightly more important |
| 3 | Moderate importance of one criterion over another |
| 4 | Between moderate and strong importance |
| 5 | Strong importance |
| 6 | Between strong and very strong importance |
| 7 | Very strong importance |
| 8 | Between very strong and absolute importance |
| 9 | Absolute importance of one criterion over another |
In this study, stakeholders are asked to express their judgements by comparing every pair of criteria and sub-criteria that affect water tariff determination. These comparisons are recorded in matrix form and processed to generate the priority weights of each factor. Scores range from 1: equal importance, to 9: one factor is absolutely more important. The assessment process is carried out through questionnaires, and supported by focus group discussions and interviews, so that participants can clarify their views before making judgements. Stakeholders were selected through purposive sampling based on their knowledge of local water services and their involvement in water tariff policies, ensuring that their opinions reflect the actual conditions of water service delivery (see Table 3). Although subjective views cannot be entirely avoided, the selection of respondents from a wide range of relevant institutions increases the credibility and diversity of judgements.
Table 3 Stakeholder information.
| No | Stakeholders | Number of participants |
| 1 | Local government officials responsible for tariff policy | 3 |
| 2 | Regional water company managers and technical experts | 4 |
| 3 | Industrial and commercial water user representatives | 2 |
| 4 | Community organizations/NGOs in water and sanitation | 3 |
| 5 | Academics and researchers on water policy | 3 |
| 6 | Community leaders | 3 |
| 7 | Households (low, middle, and high income) | 6 |
The experts were identified using academic databases such as Scopus, ResearchGate, and Web of Science to ensure that participants have a strong background in water resource management and tariff policy. The sample (n = 31) consists of 24 local stakeholders and 7 academic experts through academic databases as summarized in Tables 3 and 4. Combining the input from local stakeholders and experts provides a balanced and evidence-based weighting of criteria. This process strengthens the robustness of the AHP analysis and ensures that the proposed water tariff framework accounts for social, technical, and economic considerations.
Table 4 Expert information.
| No | Experts | Number of participants |
| 1 | International researchers on water resources and tariffs | 3 |
| 2 | Indonesian experts on water governance and public services | 4 |
3.4 Hierarchical calculation
The decision-making process in this study is based on priority weights derived from the goals, criteria, and sub-criteria, as well as scores collected through questionnaires distributed to stakeholders and experts. The priority weights of criteria and alternatives are obtained using the pairwise comparison method, where each criterion, sub-criterion, and alternative is compared with others in a square comparison matrix, as shown in the following Table 5.
Table 5 Pairwise matrix.
| A1 | A2 | ..,.. | An | |
| A1 | w1/w1 | w1/w2 | .. .. | w1/wn |
| A2 | w2/w1 | w2/w2 | .. .. | w2/wn |
| ..,.. | .. .. | .. .. | .. .. | |
| An | wn/w1 | wn/w2 | .. .. | wn/wn |
The entries in this matrix (denoted as wn/wm) correspond to the judgements made by stakeholders and experts according to Saaty’s scale (Table 2). Mathematically, the pairwise comparison matrix is expressed as A, where w is the normalized eigenvector (priority vector) and λmax is the maximum eigenvalue. The steps of the calculation are as follows:
- Construct the pairwise comparison matrix based on responses from stakeholders and experts and normalize the matrix and calculate the priority weights for each element.
- Compute the principal eigenvalue (λmax) by summing the products of the matrix values and the priority weights.
Derive the Consistency Index (CI) using Equation 1:
| (1) |
Where:
| λmax | = | maximum eigenvalue, and |
| n | = | size of the matrix. |
Then calculate the Consistency Ratio (CR) using Equation 2:
| (2) |
Where:
| RI | = | Random Index, which depends on the size of the matrix. |
Table 6 presents the RI values.
Table 6 Saaty value.
| 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | |
| RI | 0.00 | 0.00 | 0.52 | 0.89 | 1.11 | 1.25 | 1.35 | 1.40 | 1.45 |
Based on Table 6, the value of CR is less than 0.1, the judgements are considered to be consistent; otherwise, the comparisons need to be revised. Thus, in this study, the AHP analysis was applied to evaluate and prioritize the factors that influence willingness and ability to sign up for regional water company services. The criteria (accessibility, user preference, and economic condition) and their sub-criteria (as shown in Table 1) were assessed by stakeholders (Table 3), while expert evaluations were used to validate and refine the weightings. The results were processed using Expert Choice software (Expert Choice 2025) to obtain the priority ranking of factors that should be considered in developing a fair and sustainable water tariff structure.
3.5 Hierarchical sensitivity
This research also applies sensitivity analysis to see how changes in the weight of each criterion influence the ranking of alternatives for water tariff determination. Sensitivity analysis is a critical stage because it tests how stable the results are when the importance of criteria shifts. Using Expert Choice software, the analysis compares the ranking obtained from stakeholder and expert judgements with a baseline scenario where all three criteria, accessibility, user preference, and economic condition, are given equal weights (13.3% each). Moreover, this study can identify which criteria most strongly affect the final priority and whether small changes in weight lead to significant shifts in the order of alternatives.
4 Analytical Hierarchy Results
After all the questionnaires were collected from the stakeholders, the responses were processed using the Expert Choice application. Two sets of pairwise comparisons were conducted. The first set involved all stakeholders, excluding the external experts, and focused on comparing the criteria and sub-criteria. The second set involved experts who assessed the relative influence of each criterion and sub-criterion in shaping willingness and ability to sign for the regional water company services.
According to Table 7, Economic condition ranks as the most influential factor, contributing 36% to the overall decision-making process. This is followed closely by user preference at 34%, which encompasses willingness to subscribe and satisfaction with current water sources. Accessibility to water sources comes third at 30%.
Table 7 Pairwise comparison results.
| Accessibility | User preference | Economic condition | Priority vector | |
| Accessibility | 1 | 0.8 | 0.7 | 0.300 |
| User preference | 1.25 | 1 | 0.9 | 0.340 |
| Economic condition | 1.43 | 1.1 | 1 | 0.360 |
4.1 Comparison of criteria and sub-criteria
The selection of criteria and their indicators was carefully aligned with the main objective of the study, which was to identify the most influential factors for designing fair and sustainable water tariff policies. In the following Figure 2, the stakeholder panel ranked economic condition (36%) as the top priority, indicating that factors such as household income, water spending, and dwelling condition strongly influence decisions to subscribe. User preference came next with 34%, which reflects the importance of people’s willingness to subscribe and their satisfaction with the water sources they currently use. Accessibility followed with 30%, emphasizing aspects such as the distance and time required to reach water sources, as well as the quality and continuity of those sources.

Figure 2 Criteria priority comparison.
The analysis of sub-criteria reveals that willingness to subscribe (18%) stands out as the most influential factor in shaping decisions related to water tariff policy and service expansion (Figure 3). This result highlights that tariff adjustments and network expansion strategies need to consider the extent to which households are motivated to connect to the system. A strong willingness indicates that communities value improved services, whereas low willingness often signals a lack of trust, previous negative experiences, or satisfaction with alternative sources of water. Satisfaction with the existing water source (16%) ranks second. Households that consider their current source safe, reliable, and convenient tend to be less interested in switching to piped water, even if tariffs are affordable. Conversely, dissatisfaction driven by poor quality, unreliable supply, or seasonal scarcity often becomes a key driver for subscription despite potential tariff increases. Together, these two sub-criteria under user preference demonstrate the role of trust and perception as behavioral determinants.

Figure 3 Sub-criteria priority comparison.
The distance and travel time to water sources (17%) constitute a significant factor within the accessibility criterion. Greater distances and longer collection times increase the likelihood that households will value a piped connection. Similarly, the quality and continuity of available water (13%) strongly influence decision-making in areas where limited supply or contamination creates uncertainty for households. At the same time, economic capacity also plays an essential role. Household income (14%) is the most influential economic factor, followed by water-related expenditure (9%), while housing conditions (7%) and asset ownership (6%) provide further insight into long-term affordability and the resilience of households to meet recurring payments.
4.2 Comparison of alternatives
This study also evaluates and prioritizes alternative approaches to water tariff policies. Based on the synthesis of stakeholder and expert assessments, the progressive tariff model with cross-subsidies (30.2%) occupies the top position as the most acceptable approach (Figure 4). This model outperforms the other alternatives, namely a flat rate structure (17.4%), cost-recovery-oriented tariffs without subsidies (16.1%), income-based tariff schemes (14.8%), full subsidies for low-income groups (12.6%), and a consumption-quota-based block tariff (8.9%).
Figure 4 Alternative water tariff policies comparison.
According to Figure 4, this study shows that the progressive cross-subsidy structure consistently ranks highest across all sub-criteria categories. Differences emerged for the third-ranked alternative: while international experts preferred income-based tariffs, local experts leaned toward cost-recovery tariffs without subsidies due to implementation simplicity. The progressive cross-subsidy model achieved dominant scores across all dimensions. Therefore, stakeholders agreed that this model is the most inclusive because it encourages low-income households to connect to the network, distributes costs more equitably among different customer groups, and ensures the financial viability of regional water company operations.
5 Discussion
These findings indicate that economic condition is the primary determinant in tariff design (36%), echoing global trends that prioritize affordability in developing regions. While most Indonesian policies focus on utility cost recovery, our results suggest a shift toward social equity, which is a core tenet of SDG 6. This finding aligns with evidence from previous studies in developing countries, where income level and affordability strongly determine the capacity of households to access improved water services (Fuente 2019). The outcome of this analysis highlights that tariff reform must be designed with mechanisms that respond to the financial capacity of households rather than solely focusing on the full recovery of operational costs. If these constraints are not addressed, marginalized groups will remain excluded despite infrastructure improvements. This is consistent with the argument advanced by Barberán et al. (2022) that affordability constraints are central to water sector reforms. Thus, in the Indonesian context, economic vulnerability remains a structural determinant of subscription behavior and must be at the forefront of tariff-setting policies.
The next most influential factor is user preference, which carries a weight of 34 percent and includes willingness to subscribe and satisfaction with the quality of water sources. This result underscores that tariff policy is not only a matter of technical design but also one of perception, trust, and behavioral intention. Studies from India and Vietnam emphasize that dissatisfaction with unreliable supply often leads households to prefer private vendors or alternative informal sources, despite higher costs (García-Valiñas and Suárez-Fernández 2022). These patterns indicate that dissatisfaction with existing regional water company services can erode demand even when tariffs are affordable (Pinto et al. 2021). Therefore, improving service reliability and quality is as critical as addressing the affordability dimension. Policies that ignore the social dimension of preference risk underutilization of services even when infrastructure is available.
The third factor, accessibility, accounts for 30 percent and emphasizes the physical aspects of service provision, including distance to sources, travel time, and continuity of supply. Although this factor ranks lower, it remains an essential determinant of service uptake. Research conducted in sub-Saharan Africa illustrates that accessibility continues to limit access, particularly in rural and peri-urban settings, regardless of affordability (Fuente 2019; Sandoval et al. 2025). However, the weighting in this study shows that economic barriers often overshadow purely physical barriers. This means that expanding pipelines and treatment plants, while necessary, will not automatically increase connection rates without policies to address financial and behavioral dimensions. Consequently, infrastructure strategies need to be integrated with broader affordability interventions (Cook and Brent 2021).
A key contribution of this study is the prioritization of the progressive cross-subsidy tariff model as the preferred alternative. This model emerged as the most effective in balancing affordability, equity, and financial sustainability, with a weight of 30.2 percent in the multi-criteria decision-making analysis. Cross-subsidization is effective in Latin America, where it redistributes the cost burden from high-income groups to low-income households (Wen et al. 2023). In Indonesia, where income inequality persists, this model aligns with the policy imperative to provide a more inclusive service without compromising the viability of the regional water company services. The analysis demonstrates that this model can offer a structured pathway toward cost recovery while reducing the exclusion of vulnerable groups (Lopez-Nicolas et al. 2018; Wen et al. 2023). The model thereby directly responds to the dual challenges of equity and financial sustainability.
The study also reveals the limitations of purely cost-recovery-oriented tariff models. While such models aim to ensure the financial viability of water utilities, they tend to marginalize households with low income, creating long-term inequities in service delivery. With empirical evidence from Chile, Molinos-Senante et al. (2019) has shown that a strict cost recovery model can lead to persistent exclusion of peri-urban populations, with negative consequences for public health. These findings suggest that a rigid approach to cost recovery may not be compatible with the broader social mission of water utilities in developing contexts (Pinto et al. 2021). Consequently, a hybrid tariff structure that integrates social considerations through subsidies or cross-financing arrangements becomes a more viable approach. This research thus supports a paradigm shift in tariff design that goes beyond financial rationality.
Differences in preferences between international and local experts are another noteworthy outcome of this study. International experts prefer income-based tariff models as their third-ranked alternative, emphasizing the potential for targeted subsidies based on socio-economic characteristics. Conversely, local experts favor cost-recovery without subsidies as a third option due to the feasibility of implementation within Indonesia’s administrative capacity. This divergence reflects a broader tension between the ideal of precise targeting and the practical constraints of policy execution. The absence of robust household income databases in many regions makes income-based targeting challenging in the Indonesian context. Therefore, practical considerations, such as administrative simplicity and regulatory compatibility, strongly influence local preferences.
User preferences as a decisive factor suggest that water tariff reforms cannot be viewed in isolation from the broader context of service quality and institutional trust. Experience from Birmingham and Ethiopia demonstrates that low trust in utilities and dissatisfaction with service delivery undermine tariff compliance, even when prices are affordable (Rajendran et al. 2020; Reynaud et al. 2018). This evidence indicates that institutional credibility is an intangible yet powerful determinant of household decisions to subscribe (Sandoval et al. 2025). In Indonesian cases, improving trust may require transparent communication, complaint-handling mechanisms, and clear service standards (Arbués and García-Valiñas 2020). Hence, any future reforms must address the dual challenge of rebuilding institutional legitimacy while adjusting pricing. An important comparative insight can be drawn from experiences in Colombia and Brazil, where participatory mechanisms for tariff setting have significantly improved public acceptance of water tariff reforms (Ibáñez-Rueda et al. 2022). Participatory processes enhance transparency and allow stakeholders to influence decisions that directly affect them, resulting in greater legitimacy and compliance. The findings of this study suggest that such participatory governance mechanisms are largely absent in Indonesian tariff-setting processes. Strengthening community involvement in decisions about tariff adjustments could therefore enhance the accountability and legitimacy of water utilities. Such strategies would also align with broader good governance principles (Massarutto 2020; Suárez-Varela et al. 2015).
Infrastructure remains a fundamental pillar of water access, yet lessons from China show that network expansion alone cannot guarantee equitable access. Successful water programs in China combine infrastructure development with payment flexibility, pro-poor subsidies, and community engagement initiatives (Jiang et al. 2022; Wen et al. 2023; Zhong and Mol 2008). The evidence from China reinforces the conclusions of this study that access policies must be complemented by socially inclusive tariff mechanisms. For Indonesia, this means combining infrastructure investment with innovative payment strategies to reach households that are currently unconnected. Otherwise, infrastructure projects risk being underutilized by the very populations they are designed to serve. The finding that income-based models are less favored by local stakeholders highlights the limitations of data-driven targeting in contexts where household income data are incomplete or unreliable. India’s experience with Free Basic Water illustrates the difficulty of targeting subsidies based solely on income, especially when such policies are implemented at scale (von Lieres et al. 2025). In Indonesia, similar challenges could prevent income-based tariff models from achieving their intended outcomes. Thus, while the concept remains theoretically appealing, institutional readiness becomes a decisive factor. For such schemes to work, substantial investments in data collection and administrative systems would be necessary.
The prioritization of economic conditions aligns with the theoretical framework of the Water Poverty Index, which conceptualizes access as a function of resources, infrastructure, and capacity (Bel 2020). Economic resources influence both the ability of households to afford water, and their capacity to sustain access over time (Massarutto 2020). This conceptual framework supports the findings of this research, which indicate that affordability remains the key constraint in Indonesian water supply systems. Therefore, economic criteria should be integrated systematically into the formulation of tariff policies (Roibas et al. 2019; Suárez-Fernández et al. 2022). This will ensure that infrastructure development is matched with measures that enable low-income households to participate in formal water supply systems. This study also draws on insights from behavioral economics, emphasizing that perceptions of fairness and trust can be as important as financial considerations. Evidence from Bangladesh and the Philippines demonstrates that households show a higher willingness to pay when they perceive tangible improvements in service delivery, even at lower income levels (Suárez-Fernández et al. 2022). These behavioral dimensions explain why user preference emerges as the second-highest priority criterion. Tariff reforms that ignore these psycho-social dynamics risk being ineffective in motivating households to switch from unsafe sources to piped services. In this context, communication strategies that enhance trust are indispensable (Hagage et al. 2025; Suárez-Fernández et al. 2022).
These results contribute to the broader discourse on achieving Sustainable Development Goal 6, which calls for universal access to safe water and sanitation. International experience shows that progress towards SDG 6 requires a balanced policy approach that integrates affordability, governance, and behavioral incentives. This study adds to the evidence that infrastructure expansion must be accompanied by pricing policies that are sensitive to socio-economic realities. Without such integrated interventions, disparities in access to clean water will persist. Policymakers should view tariff reform as a cornerstone of broader strategies to achieve inclusive water services. The prioritization of progressive cross-subsidy models in this study mirrors the trends observed in other middle-income countries that are reforming their water supply sectors. Brazil and Mexico, for instance, have successfully adopted block tariffs with embedded cross-subsidies, enabling utilities to maintain revenue while ensuring access for the poor (Ibáñez-Rueda et al. 2022; Lopez-Nicolas et al. 2018; Suárez-Varela et al. 2015). These cases provide relevant policy lessons for Indonesia, where properly designed cross-subsidies can be both socially and financially sustainable. Incorporating similar mechanisms into local tariff policies could therefore address the dual challenges of equity and cost recovery.
In terms of governance, this discussion supports the argument that decision-making processes that actively involve multiple stakeholders generate more sustainable outcomes. Thus, it might do in a collaborative action compliance (Fuente 2019; Pronti and Berbel 2023). This research provides empirical support for this theory in the context of water tariff policy. By integrating expert opinions and community perspectives, participatory approaches should be institutionalized in the future. With increasing climate variability affecting water resources, tariff structures must be designed to encourage water conservation without excluding low-income households. Experiences in Italy show that tiered pricing models can effectively reduce consumption while maintaining affordability for basic needs (Barberán et al. 2022; Pronti and Berbel 2023). The high ranking of the progressive cross-subsidy model provides a practical roadmap for local governments to balance financial viability with universal access. This transition requires a policy shift, where high-volume or commercial users subsidize basic consumption for low-income households, as it offers a way to achieve sustainability and social justice simultaneously. Thus, climate adaptation and water governance reform can be mutually reinforcing (Bel 2020; Pinto et al. 2021).
6 Conclusion
The findings of this study confirm that reforming water tariff policies requires immediate and deliberate action to ensure both equity and sustainability in Indonesia’s urban and peri-urban areas. Regional water company services that do not adjust tariffs, expand their service networks, and strengthen social protection mechanisms face persistent financial deficits that will limit service improvements and delay network expansion. Evidence from Uganda demonstrates that utilities can expand service coverage rapidly when they combine tariff reform with institutional strengthening (Mugisha 2007). These findings also show that a water tariff policy functions not only as a financial instrument but also as a form of social contract between governments and citizens. When decision makers design tariffs that are transparent, progressive, and inclusive, they strengthen public trust, increase willingness to sign up for water services, and create long-term conditions for universal and sustainable access to safe water.
The AHP results point to several concrete policy implications. Decision makers need to prioritize a progressive cross-subsidy tariff structure that shifts a proportionate share of costs to higher-income customers while keeping tariffs affordable for low-income households. Local governments and regional water company services should implement a block tariff structure that protects the first consumption block (basic needs) at a low price, while charging higher blocks at cost-recovery levels. In parallel, utility managers must strengthen service reliability and improve communication with communities to address user preferences, as dissatisfaction with poor service reduces willingness to connect even when tariffs are affordable. Policymakers must also direct capital investments toward network expansion in low-access neighborhoods, ensuring that tariff reforms are coupled with infrastructure development so that households can access services physically as well as financially. In areas with strong income disparities, local governments can integrate household socio-economic data with tariff databases to develop targeted support for the most vulnerable while avoiding blanket subsidies. Finally, national and local institutions should institutionalize participatory decision-making mechanisms in tariff setting, ensuring that stakeholders from households, industry, and civil society can influence priorities and foster legitimacy. By linking tariff design directly to these multidimensional strategies, regional water company services can reduce financial risks, expand service coverage, and strengthen trust between citizens and public institutions.
References
- Arbués, F. and M. García-Valiñas. 2020. "Water tariffs in Spain." In: David V McQueen (ed.), Oxford Research Encyclopedia of Global Public Health. New York, NY, online edition, Oxford Academic. https://doi.org/10.1093/acrefore/9780190632366.013.246
- Arbués, F., M.Á. Garcı́a-Valiñas, and R. Martı́nez-Espiñeira. 2003. "Estimation of residential water demand: A state-of-the-art review." The Journal of Socio-Economics 32 (1): 81–102. https://doi.org/10.1016/S1053-5357(03)00005-2
- Barberán, R., J. López-Laborda, and F. Rodrigo. 2022. "The perception of residential water tariff, consumption, and cost: Evidence of its determinants using survey data." Water Resources Management 36, 2933–2952. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11269-022-03134-z
- Bel, G. 2020. "Public versus private water delivery, remunicipalization and water tariffs." Utilities Policy 62, 100982. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jup.2019.100982
- Chowdhury, A., M.K. Jha, and V.M. Chowdary. 2010. "Delineation of groundwater recharge zones and identification of artificial recharge sites in West Medinipur district, West Bengal, using RS and GIS and MCDM techniques." Environmental Earth Sciences 59, 1209–1222. https://doi.org/10.1007/s12665-009-0110-9
- Cook, J. and D. Brent. 2021. "Do households respond to the marginal or average price of piped water services?" In: David V McQueen (ed.), Oxford Research Encyclopedia of Global Public Health. New York, NY, online edn, Oxford Academic. https://doi.org/10.1093/acrefore/9780190632366.013.244
- Expert Choice, Inc. 2025. Expert Choice, version 6.2.001.42753. https://www.expertchoice.com/
- Fuente, D. 2019. "The design and evaluation of water tariffs: A systematic review." Utilities Policy 61, 100975. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jup.2019.100975
- García-Valiñas, M.Á. and S. Suárez-Fernández. 2022. "Are economic tools useful to manage residential water demand? A review of old issues and emerging topics." Water 14 (16): 2536. https://doi.org/10.3390/w14162536
- Hagage, M., A.G.A. Hewaidy, and A.M. Abdulaziz. 2025. "Saltwater intrusion and land subsidence destroy northern Nile Delta archaeological sites: An assessment using hydrochemical indices, SAR satellite imagery, and analytic hierarchy process (AHP)." Marine Pollution Bulletin 212, 117460. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.marpolbul.2024.117460
- Hajkowicz, S. and A. Higgins. 2008. "A comparison of multiple criteria analysis techniques for water resource management." European Journal of Operational Research 184 (1): 255–265. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ejor.2006.10.045
- Ibáñez-Rueda, N., J. Guardiola, and F. González-Gómez. 2022. "The role of nature contact and connectedness to nature as determinants of household water use: A case study from Spain." Water and Environment Journal 36 (2): 282–291. https://doi.org/10.1111/wej.12765
- Jiang, Y., R.A.T. Calub, and X. Zheng. 2022. "Water tariff setting and its welfare implications: Evidence from Chinese cities." Water Resources and Economics 38, 100199. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.wre.2022.100199
- Kaliraj, S., N. Chandrasekar, and N.S. Magesh. 2014. "Multispectral image analysis of suspended sediment concentration along the Southern coast of Kanyakumari, Tamil Nadu, India." Journal Coastal Science 1 (1): 63–71. https://5fe56238-0a01-426e-a652-0c8a60c7a092.filesusr.com/ugd/c39850_06848192443c474ca3d3d3e7cf50a86a.pdf
- KOMPAS. 2023. "The national drinking water loss rate still reaches 33.7 percent. Ministry of Public Works and Housing." In Indonesian. Accessed online: https://www.kompas.com/properti/read/2023/01/23/183000421/tingkat-kehilangan-air-minum-nasional-masih-tembus-33-7-persen
- Kumari, A., D. Kumar, and P. Warwade. 2021. "Application of multi-criteria decision making (MCDM) and electrical resistivity tomography (ERT) techniques for identification of groundwater recharge zone(s) in granitic hard rock aquifer." Journal of Earth System Science 130, 81. https://doi.org/10.1007/s12040-021-01577-3
- Lopez-Nicolas, A., M. Pulido-Velazquez, C. Rougé, J.J. Harou, and A. Escriva-Bou. 2018. "Design and assessment of an efficient and equitable dynamic urban water tariff. Application to the City of Valencia, Spain." Environmental Modelling and Software 101, 137–145. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.envsoft.2017.12.018
- Massarutto, A. 2020. "Servant of too many masters: Residential water pricing and the challenge of sustainability." Utilities Policy 63, 101018. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jup.2020.101018
- Molinos-Senante, M., A. Villegas, and A. Maziotis. 2019. "Are water tariffs sufficient incentives to reduce water leakages? An empirical approach for Chile." Utilities Policy 61, 100971. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jup.2019.100971
- Mugisha, S. 2007. "Performance assessment and monitoring of water infrastructure: an empirical case study of benchmarking in Uganda." Water Policy 9 (5). 475–491. https://doi.org/10.2166/wp.2007.022
- Pinto, F. S., B. de Carvalho, and R.C. Marques. 2021. "Adapting water tariffs to climate change: Linking resource availability, costs, demand, and tariff design flexibility." Journal of Cleaner Production 290, 125803. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2021.125803
- Pronti, A. and J. Berbel. 2023. "The impact of volumetric water tariffs in irrigated agriculture in Northern Italy." Environmental Impact Assessment Review 98, 106922. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.eiar.2022.106922
- Rajendran, G., M. Mohammed, S. Shivakumar, W. Merera, and K. Taddese. 2020. "Geospatial techniques amalgamated with two-dimensional electrical resistivity imaging for delineation of groundwater potential zones in West Guji Zone, Ethiopia." Groundwater for Sustainable Development 11, 100407. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.gsd.2020.100407
- Reynaud, J.F., M. Garmendia, and T. Nieva. 2018. "Comprehensive integration of Onboard Energy Storage systems in tramways: Birmingham tram case study." 2018 IEEE International Conference on Electrical Systems for Aircraft, Railway, Ship Propulsion and Road Vehicles and International Transportation Electrification Conference (ESARS-ITEC). Nottingham, UK. pp. 1–6. https://doi.org/10.1109/ESARS-ITEC.2018.8607554
- Roibas, D., M.A. Garcia-Valiñas, and R. Fernandez-Llera. 2019. "Measuring the impact of water supply interruptions on household welfare." Environmental and Resource Economics 73 (1): 159–179. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10640-018-0255-7
- Saaty, T.L. 1990. "How to make a decision: The analytic hierarchy process." European Journal of Operational Research 48 (1): 9–26. https://doi.org/10.1016/0377-2217(90)90057-I
- Sandoval, H., P. Hancevic, and H. Bejarano. 2025. "The hidden costs of tariff misclassification: Structural winners and losers." Energy Economics 144, 108322. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.eneco.2025.108322
- Sangawi, A., D.A.M. Al-Manmi, and B.Q. Aziz. 2023. "Integrated GIS, remote sensing, and electrical resistivity tomography methods for the delineation of groundwater potential zones in Sangaw Sub-Basin, Sulaymaniyah, KRG-Iraq." Water 15 (6): 1055. https://doi.org/10.3390/w15061055
- Schleich, J. and T. Hillenbrand. 2019. "Residential water demand responds asymmetrically to rising and falling prices." Applied Economics 51 (45): 4973–4981. https://doi.org/10.1080/00036846.2019.1606412
- Suárez-Fernández, S., M.A. García-Valiñas, and R. Martínez-Espiñeira. 2022. "Exploring behavioral responses to a residential water tariff reform." Water Resources and Economics 40, 100211. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.wre.2022.100211
- Suárez-Varela, M., R. Martínez-Espiñeira, and F. González-Gómez. 2015. "An analysis of the price escalation of non-linear water tariffs for domestic uses in Spain." Utilities Policy 34, 82–93. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jup.2015.01.005
- Vázquez-Serrano, J.I., L.E. Cárdenas-Barrón, J.C. Vicencio-Ortiz, N.R. Smith, R.E. Bourguet-Díaz, and A. Céspedes-Mota. 2025. "Allocation and pricing of drinking water in a sustainable closed-loop supply chain under uncertainty." Journal of Cleaner Production 521, 146051. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2025.146051
- von Lieres, J.S., A.M. Sretha, M. Nitin Kumar, N.K. Velayudhan, A.R. Devidas, and M.V. Ramesh. 2025. "Promoting water-sustainability: A participatory co-design approach for addressing water-supply challenges in urban Kerala, India." Journal of Urban Management 15 (1): 177–199. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jum.2025.06.005
- Wen, F., X. Fang, R. Khanal, and M. An. 2023. "The effect of sectoral differentiated water tariff adjustment on the water saving from water footprint perspective: A case study of Henan Province in China." Journal of Cleaner Production 393, 136152. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2023.136152
- Zhong, L-J., and A.P.J. Mol. 2008. "Participatory environmental governance in China: Public hearings on urban water tariff setting." Journal of Environmental Management 88 (4): 899–913. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jenvman.2007.04.018

